MINUTES, Q&P CONFERENCE CALL
10 AM-12 N EST, DECEMBER 4, 1998

Submitted December 24, 1998. J. Voelkel.

Check In

  1. J. Voelkel
  2. T. Boardman
  3. V. Czitrom
  4. J. Ramirez
  5. S. Schiller
  6. S. Devlin
  7. L. Vance
  8. E. Walker

 

Regrets

  1. L. Moore
  2. D. McCarville
  3. G. Vining
  4. L. Hare
  5. E. Lagergren
  6. R. Leon
  7. C. Morgan
  8. R. Fricker

Agenda

11:00 - 11:05 Check in -- Veronica

11:05 - 11:20 Review of Action Items -- Joe

11:20 - 12:45 Updates from committee chairs (approx. 5 minutes each)

Tactical Planning Meeting - Tom

Secretary - Joe

Membership - Ron

Operating Manual - Lynne

JSM Program 98 - Eric

JSM Program 99 - Dan

Continuing Education = ??

QP Research Conference - Jeff

Publications - Susannah/Mary

Newsletter - Lisa

Assoc. Newsletter/Mini paper - Esteban

Webmaster - Ramon

Council of Sections - Geoff/Lonnie

Committee to Nominate Fellows - Carolyn

Nominations committee - Tom

Treasury - Susan

12:45 - 12.55 Other business - Veronica

12:55 - 1:00 Next conference call - Veronica

Action Items from Conference Call

Previous action items, still incomplete, with comments

112. T. Boardman (had been C. Morgan, up to 12/98). Need champion for interactions with other organizations. Try Stu Hunter first., then AmStat News.

* no updated info on this.

** (6/97) (by E-mail after the call) C. has just gotten information on contacting Stu. She will try to reach him soon.

*** (8/97) Terry Ziemer (Minitab) and Stefan Steiner (U. Waterloo) have volunteered. CM will still contact Stu.

**** (10/97 CM) no response from Stu. Still working with TZ and SS.

***** (2/98 CM) Still no response from Stu. SS looking for connection with INFORMS. However, he doesn't think he'll be attending these meetings. T. Boardman will see Stu in March and discuss with Stu. In the meantime, C. Morgan will prepare an article on this for AmStat News.

****** (10/98) T. Boardman tried, but was unable, to reach Stu via e-mail. He will try to phone him again

******* (12/98) CM sent the following e-mail message, on 11/5/98 You should have received the recent email from Tom Boardman about his "chat" with Stu Hunter on the issue of interactions with other organizations. Stu is unable to do this. This is still an ongoing challenge which I think Tom may be the new leader.

******* (12/98) Tom B. will take over this responsibility.

129. R. Hoerl. Include in Chair's responsibility to send out list of Q&P meetings and events at JSM

*(10/97 RH). OK. He will do.

** (2/98 RH). Still pending.

133.E. Walker. Take up publishing Snee's article (replaces item #63). Possibilities include a shortened article in newsletter or a detailed abstract there, with pointer to the Web. May be easiest for E. W. to edit, then send to Snee for approval.

  1. J. Voelkel. Try to find a Q&P/Stat-Div liaison at the FTC.

** (12/98) JV met with two Stat Div officers at the FTC. They were unable to come up with a liaison. JV will contact new Stat Div chair (JOV: e-mail sent to Don Williams on 12/22)

149. AllÆTom Boardman. Submit the names of worthy candidates for the 1999 Fellows nominations to Joe Skwish (pqmjns@pccvax.dnet.dupont.com)

** (12/98) Tom B. will contact Joe S.

149a. (G. Vining) Plan to

** (12/98) Geoff sent an e-mail today. See Appendix C. Wants to reconvene meeting at QPRC in NY on May 18 (QPRC is May 19-21, 1999). TB will send note to confirm this. Also, see item 150.

152. (T. Boardman, handed off from E. Lagergren and L. Vance) Are E-mail lists available for members?

* 12/98. Eric sent a report in by e-mail. See Appendix B. (JOV: These recommendations should be reviewed and addressed by the incoming Chair, T. Boardman.)

  1. (L. Gill and E. Walker) See about offering Q&P members a choice for whether they want only an electronic copy of the newsletter.

* 12/98 Also, Lisa is asking members whether they would just like this on line.

  1. (L. Gill) See about adding Q&P Research Conference abstracts to the Section Proceedings (yes??). This would provide a link to these authors. Also see about adding the abstracts to the home page (yes??).
    * (10/98) Susannah-Q&P people were invited to contribute their papers in the JSM proceedings.
    * (10/98) Tom Boardman will contact Ai-Chu to add the abstracts. JOV will find the 99 Q&P person to do this as part of the process

* 12/98 VC. This should have been done (Q&P Research Conference abstracts to the Section Proceedings). Doesn't know about HP additions.

156. (E. Walker) "Reader's Digest" material

* 12/98 EW asked for clarification on this. Should we get involved in this. Also (VC), it may be better to look at the sampling book put out by the sampling section of ASA. EW also likes the Seen Elsewhere idea.

New action items

161. (T. Boardman). Send note to confirm May 18 date for next go at Review of Vision and Strategic Plan. See item 149a.
Item Description Responsibility

1

Recently Completed Action Items

Only completed action items are listed here. On-going and new items are listed above.

142. All. If your job has a job description in the Q&P Operating Manual (on the Web page): Send changes in your job description to Lynne. If no changes are needed, send him a "no update needed" message. Due by October 1.

* (10/98) L. Moore. Senior Newsletter Editor - not in OM. Lisa has a job description from SPES, but they do not yet have an OM. She will send on to SPES.

* (10/98) L. Hare. VC, CM, JV, RH, Wlet, EricL, Rfri, Ramon, Sdev, Lhare, Tboard. Others-please do ASAP (JV-send note)

* (12/98) OK

147. L. Vance. Send J. Voelkel a summary, by e-mail if possible, about the CoS meetings at the JSM.

** (12/98) Done. Lonnie sent the summary yesterday. See Appendix A.

150.(S. Devlin and V. Czitrom) Characterize Q&P members by jobs, degrees, geography.

* (10/98) VC sent SD list of all Q&P members (paper list).

* (10/98, submitted by Susan after the conf. call). ASA told me that they can not do any membership breakdowns for Q&P. I did not get the paper list of members from Veronica until 10/10. (The package looked like it had been around the world a few times.) I am tabulating by hand sex, geographic area and whether employer is academic institution, business, government, etc. I am about 3/4 through my tally. I should be able to send a report in about 1 week.

** 12/98 Susan did this. See Appendix D. We should review this. SD wanted to compare this to the ASA main body but this info is not available. More academics than she thought. Women about the same as ASA. We can use this at next meeting (item 149a).

158. All. Any articles for AmStat News? The due date for December is Nov 1. Let Susannah know by October 20.

* 12/98 OK

159. Veronica. Do the Chair's report for January, by the end of November, and send to Susannah.

* 12/98 done

160. All. Lisa Moore needs material by Oct 25 for the December issue of the newsletter.

* 12/98 OK

Item Description Responsibility

2

Updates, Committee Chairs

Tactical Planning Meeting - Tom

Nothing additional to report

Secretary - Joe

Nothing additional to report

Membership - Ron

Sent regrets. Nothing to report

Operating Manual - Lynne

Sent regrets. Nothing to report

JSM Program 98 - Eric

Nothing to report

JSM Program 99 - Dan

By e-mail, Dan said there are no new issues for the 99JSM other than people can now submit contributed papers and poster sessions to the ASA web at:

http://www.amstat.org/meetings/jsm/1999/

Continuing Education = ??

QP Research Conference - Jeff

No information received.

Publications - Susannah/Mary

Nothing else to report.

Newsletter - Lisa

Nothing else to report.

Assoc. Newsletter/Mini paper - Esteban

Nothing else to report.

Webmaster - Ramon

Nothing else to report.

Council of Sections - Geoff/Lonnie

Nothing else to report.

Committee to Nominate Fellows - Carolyn

Carolyn has asked Joe Skwish to take over this responsibility.

Nominations committee - Tom

Nothing else to report.

Treasury - Susan

Nothing else to report.



Item Description Responsibility

3

Other Business

V. Czitrom

None

Item Description Responsibility

4

Next Conference Call

The next conference call will be held some time in March, perhaps March 17 or 19. The new Chair, Tom Boardman, and/or new Secretary, Lisa Custer, will send out this information later.

 

Appendix A
Report of Council of Sections Meeting, by L. Vance

Council of Sections (COS) Annual Meeting Agenda

Sunday, August 9, 1998

1:30 p.m. - 4:00 p.m.

1:30 p.m. Welcome and Introductions (Council Chair Linda Young)

1:35 p.m. Approval of August 1997 Business Meeting Minutes (Mary Christman)

1:40 p.m. Advisory Committee on Continuing Education (ACCE) Awards (Mary Fleming)

1:45 p.m. Remarks by President David Moore

1:55 p.m. Strategic Planning Committee (Jonas Ellenberg)

2:10 p.m. ASA Constitution Committee (John McKenzie)

2:20 p.m. COS Constitution Committee (George Williams)

2:30 p.m. Discussion of ASA Board of Directors Activities (Richard Gunst)

2:45 p.m. Update of ASA Website (Bruce Trumbo)

2:55 p.m. Discussion of Issues Concerning Section Budgets and Fiscal Planning (Melinda McCann/Steve Porzio)

3:15 p.m. Poster and Project Competition (Linda Quinn)

3:25 p.m. Discussion of Recent Success Stories and Other Issues from Section Activities

3:55 p.m. Announcement regarding Section Response and Action and Follow Up Meetings on Thursday



*Order of topics may change depending upon presenter schedules

Notes by Lonnie Vance

Mary Fleming

Outreach (Statistical Thinking, etc.) headed up by Lynn Hare. Sections sometimes generate their own revenue. Share expenses.

David Moore

Would like to see strengthening of the following:

Jonas Ellenberg

Strategic Plans

 

16 examples of actions identified as high priority: Seven were Structural and Nine were Outreach. Each of these examples was covered in some detail.

Linda Young

There is some money available to help with section plans.

John McKenzie

Jan. 1, 1999 Constitution

- Committees

- Nominations

- Other Changes

George Williams

COS Constitution

Changes to several Articles were noted.

Sharon Anderson

ASA BOD Activities

Increase in JASA from $32 to $34. STATS remains the same. Schedule Joint Statistical Meetings 7 years ahead instead of the current 5 years ahead. 1999 ASA budget approved by the BOD. September 30 is the deadline for budgeting plan needs by the Sections.

Steve Porzio

What do the Sections want to see concerning Sections:

 

Linda Quinn

Poster and Project Competition

Statistical Consulting Section gave $1500. Eight sections provided some money.

Miscellaneous

 



Appendix B.
Response to action item 152:
(E. Lagergren, L. Vance) Are e-mail lists available for members?

(Sent by e-mail from Eric)

ASA is in the process of putting such lists together for each section. I contacted Nancy Hiett, Chapter & Section Project Leader at ASA, in early September. At that time she said it would take several months to put the lists together. I recently contacted her to check on the status, but have not heard back yet.

 

I would recommend using such a list, but we must be selective. Most of us receive too much "junk" email as it is. I would suggest that one person be responsible for sending email to section members. The emails should be short and targeted, e.g. a one or two-line teaser about an upcoming conference with a URL to our web page for more detailed information. I would suggest no more than one email a month, and of course an option to unsubscribe at the bottom.

 

I spoke with a colleague who is a member of the Bayesian section and he said their list originated from a conference list.

 

I would recommend just sending our Q&P brochure to new members rather than an email.

Appendix C. Note from G. Vining re Action Item 149a

Action item is

Plan to

 

As promised, here is my update on my Tactical Planning responsibility.

I am responsible to lead the work on our Vision and our strategic plan for customers. I have found that we are most productive discussing these kinds of issues when we have a critical mass of people who can meet face-to-face. In that spirit, I propose that all people interested in working on these issues plan to meet on May 18 in Schenectady, the day prior to the 1999 Q&P Research Meeting. I would appreciate it if one of the organizers can get us a meeting room at the headquarters hotel. Like last year, we should provide a way for those who cannot physically attend to participate by teleconference.

I envision two sessions for this meeting. The first one, starting in the morning, would have those physically present to start the process and to develop something for all people to react to in the afternoon. The afternoon session will be the conference call. This format seemed

to work well last year.

Of course, the success of this meeting depends heavily upon the number of people who can physically attend. Crucial people to attend are: Tom, as Chair, Veronica, as Past-Chair, and me, as Chair-Elect. Clearly, the more people we have, the better the chances we will develop something of real value to the Section.

Please let me know your reactions to this proposal. I hope to make the tail end of the call. If not, please email your suggestions to me.

Appendix D. Geographical Report on Q&P Membership,
from Susan Devlin

Q&P Section Membership Make-Up, Based on 1998 Address Lists
Sex Excluding Unknowns
Male 747 68.3% 78.7%
Female 200 18.3% 21.1%
Instit. 2 0.2% 0.2%
Unknown 145 13.3%
TOTAL 1094 100.0%
KNOWN TOTAL 949 100.0%
Employer
Business 402 36.7% 53.1%
Academic Institution 312 28.5% 41.2%
Government 36 3.3% 4.8%
Organization 7 0.6% 0.9%
Unknown 337 30.8%
TOTAL 1094 100.0%
KNOWN TOTAL 757 100.0%
State/Continent
NorthEast US 249 22.8%
NJ 63 5.8%
PA 58 5.3%
NY 52 4.8%
MA 41 3.8%
CT 20 1.8%
NH 10 0.9%
VT 3 0.3%
ME 2 0.2%
Southeast US 229 21.0%
NC 37 3.4%
VA 33 3.0%
MD 32 2.9%
FL 28 2.6%
TN 21 1.9%
MO 21 1.9%
GA 11 1.0%
SC 11 1.0%
AL 9 0.8%
DE 7 0.6%
LA 6 0.5%
DC 5 0.5%
KY 5 0.5%
WV 3 0.3%
Midwest US 231 21.2%
OH 43 3.9%
IL 41 3.8%
MI 39 3.6%
MN 32 2.9%
IN 25 2.3%
WI 21 1.9%
KS 14 1.3%
IA 9 0.8%
AK 3 0.3%
NE 3 0.3%
ID 1 0.1%
Southwest US 131 12.0%
TX 58 5.3%
CO 25 2.3%
AZ 22 2.0%
NM 12 1.1%
UT 6 0.5%
OK 5 0.5%
NV 3 0.3%
Northwest US 5 0.5%
MT 2 0.2%
WY 1 0.1%
ND 1 0.1%
SD 1 0.1%
Pacific Coast 115 10.5%
CA 86 7.9%
OR 14 1.3%
WA 12 1.1%
HI 3 0.3%
Global, excluding US 132 12.1%
Europe 48 4.4%
Asia 26 2.4%
Canada 25 2.3%
PR 9 0.8%
Mid East 8 0.7%
Africa 6 0.5%
Mexico & Carribean 5 0.5%
So. America 4 0.4%
Australia 1 0.1%
TOTAL 1092 100.0% 100.0%