Minutes, Q&P Conference Call
1-3 EST, June 12, 1996

Minutes in Adobe Acrobat Portable Document (PDF) format.

Roll call:

1. Roger Hoerl
2. Joe Voelkel
3. V. Czitrom
4. T. Boardman
5. E. Boardman
6. S. Devlin
7. R. Leon
8. L. Hare
9. C. Morgan
10. Bob Mason
11. S. Zayac

Action Items from Conference Call

Previous action items, still incomplete, with comments

25. R. Mason (With Leon) Create a process for transferring ongoing member updates on the Home Page to yearly updates to the operating manual. This is ongoing.

** still ongoing

30. V. Czitrom E-mail job description for continuing ed. to Roger and Lynne
** need to send final version to R. Mason

31. R. Hoerl (re action item 21: T. Boardman. Send note to Lynne/Roger about home page (missing buttons...)) Contact people who have not responded to Tom's requests.
** We still need SPES permission to put the joint newsletter on the Web. R. Hoerl will contact SPES again to verify this is OK, and then contact R. Leon to contact J. Buckingham.

*** Has been taken of (R. Hoerl, 6/14/96)

36. L. Hare Send a report on "moderated discussions" via E-mail when results are gotten.
** so far, little luck doing this through NIST. R. Leon suggested that he will be able to do so at some point with his server.

38. I. Sande Send updated web information to the newsletter
** to be done

39. I. Sande [slightly modified from last minutes] Ask P. Donnelly to include a regular sidebar in the newsletter to remind people how to get to the web
43. T. Boardman Check about ASQC linking to Q&P, and offer recommendations.

** done. But no response yet. 2nd request out, no response from Webmaster.

*** Have now gotten a response, and are moving on this (R. Hoerl, 6/14)

45. L. Hare Let ASA know that Q&P is using technologies well (home page, e-mail, and conference calls), by a letter to AmStat News.
** need to do

New action items

46. J. Voelkel Send stationery to L. Hare.

47. L. Hare As chair-elect, get stationery next year with web address, and write this into chair-elect's job in the operating manual.

48. J. Voelkel Contact I. Sande to send updated web information to the newsletter

49. S. Devlin With AMA, pursue research opportunities for dissemination to Q&P.

50. I. Sande Update R. Hoerl on the status of the Communications Tactical Plan.

51. L. Hare/R. Hoerl Examine list of positions to be filled.

52. V. Czitrom Ask the Q&P Conference board to find someone to edit the global web page

53. All Send ideas to T. Crosby for 1997 JSM invited sessions.

54. V. Czitrom Send the portion of the Q&P Research Conference manual on budget information, and on conference organizers, to S. Devlin.

55. S. Devlin Contact appropriate Q&P Research Conference organizers to handle budget issues and responsibilities (per item 6 of these minutes).

56. All officers and committee leaders. Update your job description by the JSM, and present the update to R. Mason. (E-mail, fax, in person...)

57. L. Hare Find a person to handle the Continuing Education courses for 1997.

58. All Send ideas on a person to handle the Continuing Education courses for 1997 to Lynne.

Agenda

Draft Agenda For 6/12/96 Conference Call - 1:00 - 3:00 PM Eastern

1. Roll Call - Roger 5 min

2. Update on To-Do's From Last Call - All 15 min

3. Update of the Four Priority Projects for 1996 20 min

-Partnership With ASQC Stat Div - Roger

-Continuing Education - Veronica

-Communication - Tim

-Web/Emerging Technologies - Lynne/Ramon/Tom & Eileen

4. Brief Updates on All Existing Activities 75 min

NOTE: These updates are for communications and to raise any issues, we do

not have time to problem-solve each one. If significant issues arise, we

can schedule another call with interested parties to resolve it. The

following are in pseudo random order:

-Committee to Nominate Fellows - Carolyn Morgan

-Nominations Committee - Lynne Hare

-Q&P Research Conference - Jeff Hooper

-Publications - Steve Zayac

-Membership Committee - Innis Sande

-Newsletter - Pat Donnelly

-96 JSM Program

-97 JSM Program

-Charter Committee - Bob Mason

-Treasurer's Report - Susan Devlin

-Council of Sections Report - Jim Hess and Eileen Boardman

-Update on Q&P Section Meetings at JSM - Roger Hoerl

-Update on Tactical Planning Meeting at JSM - Lynne Hare

-Update on Operating Manual - Bob Mason

-Continuing Education Courses for 97 - Veronica Czitrom and Lynne Hare

5. Schedule Next Call

New Items

Item       Description                                     Responsibility          
1          Update on action items of 3/20/96 conf. call    R. Hoerl                
           24. I. Sande   Check with ASA on status of member list being done       
           with ASA. (ongoing debate on this. Innis will keep Q&P apprised.)
** done. ASA to assume members agree to be listed unless the member tells ASA otherwise.** 28. R Hoerl (re action item 17: Discuss setting up focus group room/audience in Chicago.) Will contact ASA to get this information now.
** done. ASA to make up poster. ** 29. J. Voelkel E-mail out any tactical plans that have not yet been sent.
** done. In previous minutes ** 32. Hoerl Send an update on the SD project on statistical thinking to P. Donnelly for the Q&P Newsletter.
** done ** 33. R. Mason Send information on the SD How-To Series into AmStat News in the next month.
** done ** 34. V. Czitrom Send abstracts of the CE courses to T. Boardman, for the home page.
** done ** 35. L. Hare Hold a separate conference call with R. Leon, T. Read, et al. to discuss what issue to consider in emerging technologies (e.g. Operating Manual on the home page.)
** done. See below. 37. L. Hare Consider organizing a break-out group at the upcoming JSM for web issues
** OK **. 40. R. Hoerl Send out an early agenda for the 5/23 conference call.
** done ** 41. R. Hoerl Send copy of Q&P brochure to T. Boardman and R. Leon [5/1/96, JOV: these have been sent out the Q&P officers and to R. Leon.] ** done ** 42. R. Hoerl Bring brochures to SD booth at the AQC and to the Q&P Research conference
** done. Plus some to LH for Q&P ** 44. J. Voelkel Send out stationery to officers.
** done, for those who requested it. **

Item       Description                                     Responsibility          
2          ASQC Stat Division Tactical Plan. Status.       Roger Hoerl             
           "1. Share info on SD projects in AmStat News and the Q&P Newsletter     
           and home page (along with pointers to Stat Division)." status: an       
           article on this has been submitted to AmStat News. Still need to send   
           an update on the SD project on statistical thinking to P. Donnelly      
           for the Q&P Newsletter. "2. Provide Q&P with access to Stat             
           Division's How-To Series of books. This information will be             
           distributed as just described." A listing of the How To's, via R.       
           Mason, is now on our home page. R. Mason will be getting this           
           information into AmStat News in the next month. "3. Stat Division to    
           identify research opportunities, to be disseminated to Q&P." status:    
           Initial contact made. Still need to identify a person in SD to move     
           this. 4. Joe Voelkel is the official liaison between Q&P and the Stat   
           Division.  R. Hoerl said that items 1, 2, and 4 have been completed.    
           For item 3, S. Devlin felt she could be more effective looking for      
           opportunities in AMA (American Management Association) rather that      
           through ASQC, since she has more contacts in the AMA. She will pursue   
           this route.                                                             

Item       Description                                     Responsibility          
3          Continuing Education Tactical Plan. Status      V. Czitrom              
           Nothing new here really. S. Devlin's course at JSM initially went       
           through the cracks, but is OK now. The plan is to offer C.E. courses    
           at next year's JSM. One possibility is a course from Jim Filliben at    
           NIST, who gave a nice EDA talk at the May Q&P Research Conference.      

Item       Description                                     Responsibility          
4          Emerging Technologies T.P. Status               L. Hare                 
           Per action item 35, L. Hare held a conference call with T. Boardman,    
           R. Leon, and I. Sande to discuss what issues to consider in emerging    
           technologies. They came up with list of 5 items that seemed to be       
           key. This has been submitted to the newsletter in an article that       
           requests feedback from Q&P members.                                     

Item       Description                                     Responsibility          
5          Communications Tactical Plan. Status.           Tim Read, Innis Sande   
           Neither I. Sande nor T. Read were able to be on the conference call.    
           I. Sande will update R. Hoerl with the plan. Because of T. Read's       
           extensive international travel, I. Sande will have primary              
           responsibility.                                                         

Item       Description                                     Responsibility          
6          Brief Updates on Existing Activities.           Roger Hoerl             
           Committee to Nominate Fellows - Carolyn Morgan  Other committee         
           members are R. Lundegard  and J Cornell. C. Morgan talked with the      
           ASA Committee for ideas. The committee needs (a) names of people to     
           nominate and (b) people to do the work (letters, phone calls, ... )     
           to push for the work to get done.  So far, she is still waiting for a   
           list of section members and section fellows. Then they will begin the   
           search for good candidates. In the next newsletter, an article will     
           explain the existence and purpose of the committee, and will make a     
           request to submit names. They want names submitted by 12/1 to keep on   
           time. T. Boardman, as the first chair of this committee, recommended    
           that candidates' names are kept private to avoid potential              
           embarrassment. Nominations Committee - Lynne Hare Lynne will review     
           milestones (in the operating manual). R. Hoerl will contact Lynne to    
           go down the list of positions to be filled. Q&P Research Conference -   
           Jeff Hooper  L. Hare said the conference was well attended (N=207).     
           Appears to have been very positive, with an excellent program.          
           Congratulation to Eric Lagergren and Raghu Kacker. V. Czitrom is the    
           program chair next year.  R. Leon said that an editor is needed to      
           keep the global page for the conference up to date. (Note--R. Leon is   
           the Webmaster. Also, the specifics for each year are handled by the     
           local committee.) V. Czitrom will ask the conference board to find      
           someone to edit the global page.  It was agreed to avoid proceedings    
           - too much of a hassle. S. Zayac will notify SPES of this, and give     
           our permission for them to include these talks in their proceedings,    
           if they are willing to do the work. Publications - Steve Zayac          
           (reported by Steve in the conference call. The below is based on an     
           E-mail summary of his report).  SPES will contact speakers from the     
           joint Q&P Research Conference held at NIST to inquire if they'd like    
           to submit for publication in SPES Proceedings. Speakers will be         
           advised that this is optional.  Q&P policy has been not to publish to   
           encourage free discussion and allow industry speakers more              
           flexibility.  Next AmStat news submission will include member-focused   
           summary of our conference call - plus whatever other news get           
           forwarded to me.  New news? Membership Committee - Innis Sande  R.      
           Hoerl said we are advertising the open discussion session on the role   
           of SPC and DOE in TQM. ASA will advertise this with a poster at the     
           JSM and will also advertise this in AmStat news. Newsletter - Pat       
           Donnelly   The newsletter was just printed yesterday.  96 JSM Program   
           96 JSM. R. Hoerl said that R. Mee put Q&P information on the Web        
           page. 97 JSM Program  T. Crosby will be traveling until the end of      
           June. She's looking for ideas for invited sessions, and has put a       
           request in the newsletter. The first meeting for the 97 JSM is this     
           August. The invited session ideas need to be gotten by then. Please     
           send ideas to Teri soon. Charter Committee - Bob Mason  R. Mason will   
           be reviewing the charter. To be done once each 3 years Treasurer's      
           Report - Susan Devlin  Things are far behind at ASA, due to             
           new-computer problems. The updated report from last year is not even    
           available yet. Hard to even get phone calls returned.  Per Penny,       
           recommendations from ASA, only the Treasurer and the Chair can          
           approve expenses. Also, the Treasurer should be copied on all           
           approvals made by the Chair.  Right now, S. Devlin has no idea of       
           status of expense this year. R. Hoerl pointed out that this should      
           not get in the way of conducting business.  The Q&P Research            
           Conference has a separate treasurer, but the money flows through the    
           Q&P Section. The Q&P Treasurer should be copied on such expenses, but   
           does not need to give approval.  R. Leon emphasize the need for a       
           prior written agreement with the host site, with an treasurer           
           independent of the host site, based on his experience at UT. (Having    
           such an agreement is in the manual for the conference.) L. Hare         
           pointed out that this year was an exception, since NIST, the host       
           site, took the financial risk and so kept the excess. S. Devlin will    
           contact some Q&P Conference organizers to work out the above issues     
           ahead of time. SD s/she be in contact ahead of time with someone at     
           the conference. V. Czitrom will get the portion of the Q&P Research     
           Conference manual on budgets.  S. Devlin wants to give a formal         
           report to ASA in August.  Penny has asked for section help in making    
           improvements. S. Devlin will call back an volunteer the Section's       
           help  The person at ASA who handled section budgets was also            
           responsible for section lists in the past, but this is no longer so.    
           As a result, no such lists are being mailed, so there are no checks     
           here on dues coming in [RH - is this how you read this?]. ASA is        
           working on it. Council of Sections Report - Jim Hess and Eileen         
           Boardman (reported by Eileen in the conference call. The below is       
           based on an E-mail summary of her report).  Items from the board of     
           directors meeting were:  1.  Three proposals were passed regarding      
           continuing education. (1) A new honorarium structure was established    
           for invited courses to be able to provide more incentive to members     
           to give highly popular offerings at ASA as opposed to privately.  (2)   
           Fees were increased about 5%. and (3) A new revenue sharing formula     
           for cosponsored courses provides for a 50/50 split between ASA and      
           the cosponsoring group of the difference between the individual         
           course generated fees and the individual course expenses. 2.            
           Professional opportunities ads will be on the home page. 3.             
           Electronic publishing issues will be addressed after we get an          
           electronic editor. 4.  The on-line directory will utilize a more        
           aggressive passive permission approach.  Lorraine Denby has the         
           details. 5.  There is a strategic planning committee at work.  Their    
           goal is to provide a 10 year plan for ASA. 6.  The 2 board planning     
           teams for this year are Membership Services and Outreach.  Anyone       
           with ideas please pass them along to any of the board members. Update   
           on Q&P Section Meetings at JSM - Roger Hoerl  Four meeting are          
           planned. RH is waiting for ASA confirmation on times, which in          
           general are approved. 1. Annual Tactical Planning Meeting. Sun 8/4      
           2-6 PM 2. Executive Committee Meeting Tues. 8/6 7-8:30 AM. 3. Open      
           Business (Members) Meeting, joint with SPES Tues. 8/6 6:00-7:30 PM,     
           with refreshments (Note: this was originally scheduled for 6:30-8:00.   
           JOV 6/21/96.) 4. Discussion Section Meeting on SPC and DOE in TQM (I.   
           Sande) Wed 8/7 8:30-10:20 AM (This time conflicts with a short course   
           but was the best that could be done...). Update on Tactical Planning    
           Meeting at JSM - Lynne Hare  LH is hoping that 2-6 PM time is solid.    
           Plan is to follow up on action items form last year's meeting in        
           Orlando. Also wants to discuss the Web page, hopefully with feedback    
           from newsletter as mentioned above. Update on Operating Manual - Bob    
           Mason  Each officer and committee leader--update your job description   
           by the August meetings, so he can revise the manual by the Fall. R.     
           Hoerl emphasized the importance of doing this job. Continuing           
           Education Courses for 97 - Veronica Czitrom and Lynne Hare  R. Hoerl    
           asked VC to write up ideas for improvements. LH to find a new person    
           to do this. T. Boardman said it's a good idea to select the person      
           prior to the JSM. LH will discuss ideas for names with VC. Doe anyone   
           have any ideas here?                                                    

Item       Description                                     Responsibility          
7          Schedule next conference call.                  Roger Hoerl             
           The next call will be on September 20, 1-2 PM EST. This call is one     
           of the "short calls".